WhatsApp to challenge €225m Data Commission fine

ireland
Whatsapp To Challenge €225M Data Commission Fine Whatsapp To Challenge €225M Data Commission Fine
The Data Protectioner Commissioner (DPC) fined WhatsApp earlier this year after it held that the messaging service had failed to comply with its obligations under GDPR. Photo: Press Association Images
Share this article

The European arm of WhatsApp has secured permission from a High Court judge to challenge a decision of the Data Protection Commission (DPC) to fine it €225 million.

The fine was handed out by the DPC last August after it held that the messaging service had failed to comply with its obligations under the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) on data protection in several respects.

WhatsApp Ireland Ltd, which is owned by Facebook, commenced its legal challenge against the decision in September.

The High Court adjourned the matter and said that the application to have the DPC's decision judicially reviewed should be made in the presence of lawyers for the respondents in the action, namely the commission, Ireland and the Attorney General.

At the High Court on Monday, Declan McGrath SC for WhatsApp Ireland said his client's application for permission or leave to bring the action was not being opposed.

Advertisement

Counsel also said the respondents were not objecting to his client's application to amend some technical aspects of its judicial review proceedings.

The matter came before Mr Justice Anthony Barr, who agreed to grant WhatsApp permission to bring its challenge. The judge adjourned the matter to a date next month.

Judical review

In its judicial review proceedings against the DPC, Ireland and the Attorney General, WhatsApp seeks an order quashing the DPC decision of August 20th, 2020 to fine the company.

It also seeks declarations from the court, including those certain provisions of the 2018 Data Protection Act are invalid and unconstitutional, and are incompatible with the State's obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

Previously, the High Court heard the DPC, which was established under the 2018 Data Protection Act, commenced by its own volition an inquiry into WhatsApp, which is owned by Facebook, in 2018

The investigation looked at issues including the service's processing of the data of users and non-users of WhatsApp's services, and the sharing of personal data between WhatsApp and Facebook companies.

Last August the DPC made certain findings against WhatsApp. As well as imposing the fine, the DPC ordered WhatsApp to bring its data processing operation into compliance with GDPR requirements.

However, WhatsApp Ireland Ltd, which is the messaging service's provider in the European region, claims the DPC's decision is unconstitutional and incompatible with the ECHR.

WhatsApp claims the DPC's decision, which it made under sections of the 2018 Act, is flawed and should be set aside in its entirety.

The 2018 Act allows the DPC to engage in a form of administration of justice that is not permissible and is contrary to the Irish constitution, it argues. WhatsApp claims, the fine constitutes the imposition of a criminal sanction.

The size of the fine constitutes an interference with WhatsApp's Constitutional property rights, it also claims. WhatsApp further alleges that its rights to fair procedures have been breached.

Separately to the judicial review proceedings, WhatsApp has also lodged a statutory appeal before the Irish courts against the DPC's decision.

Read More

Want us to email you top stories each lunch time?

Download our Apps
© BreakingNews.ie 2022, developed by Square1 and powered by PublisherPlus.com