How could hardline US House Republicans strip Kevin McCarthy of his speakership?

explained
How Could Hardline Us House Republicans Strip Kevin Mccarthy Of His Speakership?
Explained: How could hardline US House Republicans strip Kevin McCarthy of his speakership? Photo: Getty Images
Share this article

Thomson Reuters

As Republican US House of Representatives speaker Kevin McCarthy struggles to negotiate a deal to keep the government open, he faces a challenge from his right flank, with hardline members of his caucus threatening to oust him as their leader.

To do so, they would need to invoke what's called the "motion to vacate."

Advertisement

What is the motion to vacate?

The motion to vacate is the House's procedure to remove its speaker. The chamber's current rules allow any one member, Democrat or Republican, to introduce the motion. If it is introduced as a "privileged" resolution, the House must consider it at some point, although it could be delayed by procedural votes.

If the motion to vacate comes to the House floor for a vote, it would only need a simple majority to pass. Republicans currently control the House with 221 seats to 212 Democrats, meaning if Mr McCarthy wants to keep his speaker's gavel he cannot afford to lose more than four votes.

What is the background to this rule?

Mr McCarthy endured a brutal 15 rounds of voting in January before being elected as speaker, during which he agreed to multiple concessions increasing the power of Republican hardliners.

One was the decision to allow just one member to put forward a motion to vacate, which meant that hardliners could threaten Mr McCarthy's speakership at any time.

Advertisement

This was a change from the rules in place under his Democratic predecessor, Nancy Pelosi, when a majority of one party needed to support a motion to vacate to bring it to the floor.

Who has been talking about filing a motion to vacate?

Republican Representative Matt Gaetz, a hardline conservative from Florida and perpetual thorn in Mr McCarthy's side, has repeatedly threatened to file a motion to vacate. The speaker has been unfazed.

In a September 14th closed-door meeting of House Republicans, Mr McCarthy dared Mr Gaetz to bring a motion to the floor.

World
Is America heading towards its last election in 20...
Read More

Others, including Representatives Dan Bishop and Eli Crane have also suggested they would support a motion to vacate.

Advertisement

Has the motion to vacate been used before>

The motion was first used in 1910, when then-Republican speaker Joseph Cannon put forward the motion himself to force detractors in his own party to make a decision on whether they supported him or not, according to the House Archives. The motion failed.

Then-Republican Speaker Newt Gingrich was threatened with a motion to vacate in 1997. Although he managed to tamp down resistance and avoid an actual resolution being filed, he resigned in 1998 after disappointing results in the midterm elections that year.

Republican then-Representative Mark Meadows in 2015 filed a motion to vacate against Republican speaker John Boehner. It did not come to a vote but Mr Boehner resigned anyway a few months later, citing the challenges of managing a burgeoning hardline conservative faction of his party.

Read More

Message submitting... Thank you for waiting.

Want us to email you top stories each lunch time?

Download our Apps
© BreakingNews.ie 2024, developed by Square1 and powered by PublisherPlus.com