Troubles legacy legislation a ‘bitter pill’ to swallow for some victims – commissioner

ireland
Troubles Legacy Legislation A ‘Bitter Pill’ To Swallow For Some Victims – Commissioner Troubles Legacy Legislation A ‘Bitter Pill’ To Swallow For Some Victims – Commissioner
The British government has been criticised for the legislation which will give those deemed to have co-operated with an information retrieval body immunity from Troubles-era crimes. Photo: PA Images
Share this article

Rebecca Black, PA

New legislation from the British government which aims to draw a line under the Troubles has been described as a “very bitter pill” for victims to swallow.

The Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill will see immunity from prosecution for Troubles-era crimes be offered to those who are deemed to have co-operated with an information retrieval body.

It will also close down future inquests and investigations, with a new independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR) to be put in place.

Those deemed to have co-operated with the commission will be offered immunity from prosecution.

Conversations are set to take place with Operation Kenova and the Police Ombudsman about setting their workload for the next year before wrapping up their legacy work.

The commission is planned to be led by a senior judge for five years, with likely two teams of qualified investigators and funding of £30 million (€35.4 million) per year.

Advertisement

The bill will also expand the prisoner release scheme qualification from 1973-1966, fixing what the British government regarded as an “anomaly”.

Most political parties and victims groups as well as Amnesty International have expressed concern and opposition to the plans.

On Wednesday morning, Northern Ireland’s commissioner for victims and survivors Ian Jeffers said it was a “very bitter pill to swallow” for victims.

John Teggart, son of victim Daniel Teggart demonstrating with some of the families of the 11 people killed by British soldiers in Ballymurphy in west Belfast in 1971 (Liam McBurney/PA)

“It does feel as if some of the last chances for what some victims would say is justice has been removed,” he told the BBC.

“Everybody recognises it’s 40 years, it’s 50 years, the chances of a conviction are very slim.

“But if you’ve lost your mother or your son are you going to genuinely give that up?

“I think that’s the big issue we’ve got to talk through with victims and survivors over the coming weeks.”

Meanwhile, Kieran McEvoy, professor of law and transitional justice at the Queen’s University in Belfast, compared the proposals to the truth recovery process which took place in South Africa in the 1990s where immunity was offered for information.

However, he said the South African model was very different, with full disclosure required in quasi legal hearings, determined by a judge, adding that a large number of applications for immunity were rejected.

Advertisement

“In this context, you’re talking about a subjective test where the person honestly believed they were telling the full truth, and if that is the case they must be granted an amnesty,” he told the BBC.

“So what it looks to me is like trying to find the easiest legal and political route to granting an amnesty and nothing like the same attention being applied to ensuring that victims get the full truth of what actually happened.”

However, Veterans Commissioner Danny Kinahan said he believed the legislation was “a step in the right direction”.

He said he was confident that soldiers “want to come forward” and provide information to the commission.

Read More

Want us to email you top stories each lunch time?

Download our Apps
© BreakingNews.ie 2022, developed by Square1 and powered by PublisherPlus.com