Former Limerick hurler tells High Court he was 'emasculated and mentally destroyed' by work injury

ireland
Former Limerick Hurler Tells High Court He Was 'Emasculated And Mentally Destroyed' By Work Injury
Mr Keane has taken his case against Johnson & Johnson Vision Care (Ireland) at their plant in the National Technological Park, Plassey, Co Limerick, over the incident that occurred in September 2018. Photo: Collins
Share this article

High Court Reporters

A former Limerick senior hurler is in his second day of giving evidence at the High Court over "severe" and "emasculating" injuries he sustained when he went to the aid of a co-worker who caught his arm inside machinery at a Johnson & Johnson factory in Limerick.

Mark Keane told the High Court on Friday that he felt “emasculated and mentally destroyed” because of the injury's effects, which began on "day one", and that he was "not the man he was, nor the one he hoped to become".

Advertisement

An accomplished hurler, Mr Keane won three consecutive All-Irelands with Limerick under 21s between 2000 and 2002 and played senior from 2000 to 2006.

Mr Keane has taken his case against Johnson & Johnson Vision Care (Ireland) at their plant in the National Technological Park, Plassey, Co Limerick, over the incident that occurred in September 2018.

The 43-year-old is alleging Johnson & Johnson were negligent and breached their duty towards him on September 10th, 2018, while he was working as a technician making contact lenses.

At the High Court on Friday, Mr Keane says he suffered a “huge deformity” to his hand during the incident, has not worked since, and still suffers pain in his right little finger that runs up his arm to his neck and back down.

Advertisement

Mr Keane has told the court he was on the factory floor when a colleague caught their hand in a machine on the line next to him and started "roaring" in pain. Mr Keane said he ran to help his colleague but because the man could not free his arm, his body formed a barrier between the plaintiff and a release lever which could have freed the arm.

The plaintiff has told Mr Justice Paul Coffey that he tried to reach into the machine but got his own hand caught on some internal gridding or railing and the right hand of his little finger was bent backwards.

He then took the weight of the lid, top and plate of the machine and managed to hold it ajar for 30-60 seconds until co-workers arrived with a crowbar and freed the co-worker.

Mr Keane's lawyers, HOMS Assist, submit that this incident caused the plaintiff to suffer sustained, continuous and severe personal injury, as well as loss, damage, inconvenience and expense.

Advertisement

At the High Court today, Mr Keane, a recovering alcoholic of many years, told his barrister, Andrew James Walker SC, that he was now on social welfare due to the incident, could not afford counselling any more and that he suffered with his mental health.

Mr Keane outlined to his barrister various surgeries, physiotherapies, consultations, medical treatments, scans and injections he has undergone in the intervening years but says he is still left in pain.

The plaintiff said that the company had stopped paying him in December 2022 and that he could not get another job with them or elsewhere, despite his efforts, and is now on invalidity pension.

Mr Keane said he was "demoralised, hurt, angry, made feel worthless... it's not just about me, it's about what they've done to my family".

Advertisement

"When I was an able-bodied person I loved it, I loved working there, loved what they had given me and what I could provide. I could put my daughters through college, there was something in the fridge and I could pay my bills," he said.

Mr Keane said his current insecurity is "not nice, because I came from a place where I was in a hole in the ground, to better myself. I was very, very happy and secure in myself".

He said that "in thirty seconds my whole life, my kids' and wife's life was turned upside down and then to be treated like a pariah because you saved a person is not nice".

Mr Keane is claiming he was “let down” by Johnson & Johnson who failed to provide him with a safe place of work and a safe system of work and is seeking damages.

Advertisement

The plaintiff said he was a recovering alcoholic and that while he did get some pain injections he did not want to take strong oral medication and used paracetamol, as his priority was staying sober, "to protect myself" but still struggled.

He said there were "horror stories" he knew of about people orally taking powerful medication and becoming addicted to it.

Mr Keane said he was "lucky" to be off alcohol for years but some days were a "massive struggle".

"If you add in the pain, I'm only two feet away from being back in a hole," he said.

The case continues at the High Court next week.

Read More

Message submitting... Thank you for waiting.

Want us to email you top stories each lunch time?

Download our Apps