With hopes and integrity on the line, presidential debate ends up being an anti-climax

Hamlet without the Prince. The empty chair, The B-listers.

With hopes and integrity on the line, presidential debate ends up being an anti-climax

Hamlet without the Prince. The empty chair, The B-listers.

Whatever way you came at it, there was an inevitable sense of anti-climax to the first presidential TV debate since the disastrous Frontline affair in 2011, writes Political Editor, Daniel McConnell

With President Michael D Higgins and Sean Gallagher as no-shows, the other four came with their hopes and integrity on the line.

Not one of the four contenders — Joan Freeman, Gavin Duffy, Liadh Ní Riada, and Peter Casey — managed to poll in double digits in last week’s Red C poll for Paddy Power and between them they accounted for just 16% of the field.

The early exchanges followed a similar path to the radio debate last Saturday on RTÉ.

There was plenty of bashing of Michael D’s decision not to participate in the TV debate and of Mr Gallagher’s decision to “hide” behind that. Ms Ní Riada said it was a real sign of contempt for the pair not to show up.

It disrespects the office that you are above the ordinary people,” she said.

After Mr Casey made the claim the President’s dog has cost €10,000 in grooming fees, paid for by the taxpayer, presenter Claire Byrne read a statement from the Áras to say the allegation was false.

Cue outrage from the candidates, who turned on Ms Byrne for giving airtime to someone who had not bothered to show up.

“It is his job to show up,” said several candidates.

Minutes before the off, as the candidates posed for the cameras with Ms Byrne on the set, visible nerves were on show.

Mr Duffy sought assurances from his PR man Richard Moore that his podium was workable.

Ahead of the debate, in pre-emptive strikes, the two non-attendees exchanged letters about their decision not to participate.

The runner-up of the 2011 campaign and victim from the Frontline debacle, Mr Gallagher penned a missive to Michael D, and leaked it to the media to be sure, about the President’s snub.

Mr Gallagher sent a letter to the Áras on Sunday night to vent his disappointment that because of Michael D’s decision not appear, he would not appear.

I note there are no public engagements in your diary for Monday that preclude you from participating in the Claire Byrne Live debate and your decision, as stated by you, is a political one in the context of this campaign,” he barbed.

He accused the incumbent and front runner in the race of “insulting” the Irish people by not taking part.

“I am disappointed by your decision and believe it is insulting to the people of Ireland and shows contempt for the integrity of our electoral process. In the event you reflect on your position, I have left a space in my schedule to participate in the Claire Byrne Live debate.”

Then, mid-to-late afternoon, a response came — not from Michael D, but from his campaign manager, Claire Power.

First thing she did was to rap Gallagher’s knuckles for sending the letter to the Áras about a campaign matter, “for obvious reasons”.

“I refer to your correspondence received at Áras an Uachtaráin late on Sunday night, 14th October.

President Michael D Higgins’ election headquarters is located at 14-16 Lord Edward Street, Dublin. May I request that any further correspondence in relation to any aspect of the election campaign is directed to the Michael D Higgins Campaign Office, not Áras an Uachtaráin, for obvious reasons,” she wrote.

“Let me confirm that President Michael D Higgins will fulfil the debate engagements that he announced publicly on October 2nd. Can I say that I was surprised to receive your missive last night before the airing of one particular debate. As noted above President Higgins publicly indicated his commitment to debates 12 days ago.”

Ms Ní Riada, in turn, then hit out at Mr Gallagher.

She said: “Seán, stop hiding behind Michael D and show up for all the debates. No one should have a misplaced sense of entitlement in this election. Not credible to stand for office and not turn up to debate the issue.”

more courts articles

Defendant in Cobh murder case further remanded in custody Defendant in Cobh murder case further remanded in custody
Further charges to be brought against accused in MV Matthew drugs haul case Further charges to be brought against accused in MV Matthew drugs haul case
Football fan given banning order after mocking Munich air disaster Football fan given banning order after mocking Munich air disaster

More in this section

Trump and the risk of a US debt default Trump and the risk of a US debt default
Dramatic portrait of sad scared young woman on smart mobile phone suffering cyber bullying and harassment. feeling lonely, depre Can AI image generators be policed to prevent explicit deepfakes of children? 
The West defends Israel’s skies. Not doing the same for Ukraine is a deadly mistake The West defends Israel’s skies. Not doing the same for Ukraine is a deadly mistake
Lunchtime News
Newsletter

Keep up with the stories of the day with our lunchtime news wrap.

Sign up
Revoiced
Newsletter

Sign up to the best reads of the week from irishexaminer.com selected just for you.

Sign up
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited