FA chief confident England have 'rock solid' case in poppy dispute with FIFA

"I'm confident our legal position is right and our moral position is right."

FA chief confident England have 'rock solid' case in poppy dispute with FIFA

English Football Association chief executive Martin Glenn has warned FIFA he will fight any attempt to fine England for wearing poppies in Friday's World Cup qualifier against Scotland, describing the FA's case as "rock solid".

But the Football Association of Wales has conceded defeat in its bid to wear a poppy against Serbia, saying players will don black armbands instead as the organisation cannot "take the risk" of a FIFA fine or point deduction.

Northern Ireland's players will do the same in their clash with Azerbaijan, but there will still be a minute's silence at Windsor Park on Friday night, while a card motif featuring a poppy will also be displayed in the West Stand along with other Armistice Day tributes.

England and Scotland are set to defy FIFA's ban on messages that it considers to be commercial, personal, political or religious by wearing black armbands with embroidered poppies to mark Armistice Day.

The FA and Scottish FA had hoped to do this without punishment - as they and the FAW had done in three November friendlies in 2011 - but the new regime at world football's governing body has refused to sanction this exception to the game's laws.

This was confirmed by FIFA general secretary Fatma Samoura during a visit to London last week, when she reiterated law four, paragraph four, that states players' equipment must be free from messages that could cause offence.

Samoura pointed out this law was brought in by the International Football Association Board, which is comprised of the four British home nations and FIFA, and said it must be "applied uniformly" for it to have authority.

The former United Nations diplomat did not say the English and Scottish would definitely be punished for flouting this law but recent decisions by FIFA's disciplinary committee suggest a fine is likely.

But speaking to journalists at a Sport Industry Breakfast Club event in London, Glenn said: "If (FIFA) fine us, we'll contest. They have much bigger problems they should be concentrating on.

"I'm confident our legal position is right and our moral position is right. Our case is absolutely rock solid."

Glenn, FA chairman Greg Clarke and their counterparts at the SFA have previously said they do not think wearing a poppy to commemorate those who have died in armed conflicts is a political message, and have said the 2011 compromise agreed with the previous leadership at FIFA should apply.

Press Association Sport, however, understands that new FIFA president Gianni Infantino and Samoura believe that decision was a mistake and find it hard to understand why the home nations cannot see that this might create a precedent for other nations to break the rules as they see fit.

The first stage in any disciplinary process that might follow Friday's game would be for FIFA's match commissioner at Wembley to include the armbands in their report - given the enormous publicity this saga has attracted, including an intervention from Prime Minister Theresa May, it is very hard to see how this will not happen.

The case would then go to FIFA's disciplinary committee, which would announce its decision a few weeks later. A points deduction is the most serious sanction available but a fine is considered to be more likely.

The British FAs would then have an opportunity to challenge that fine via FIFA's appeals process and a further chance to appeal at the Court of Arbitration for Sport, a course of action that would probably cost more than the fine.

Glenn also revealed that the FA's financial strength - its revenues are forecast to grow by 35 per cent to £420million in 2018 - means it does not depend on FIFA to the same extent as most other member associations.

"We don't need FIFA's money," he said. "That probably allows us to be a bit more principled - they might see it as aloof."

That is not the position for the FAW.

Chief executive Jonathan Ford said: "The FAW naturally wishes to respect and honour those who fought and lost their lives fighting for their country.

"As an Association we have to respect the rules of FIFA and following long discussions with members of the FAW Council, staff, management and players, a decision has been made not wear the poppy against Serbia.

"We felt unable to take the risk of a financial penalty or point deduction, however as we always have done at this time of year, we will be paying our respects in other ways."

As well as the wearing of black armbands, fans at Cardiff City Stadium will form a poppy mosaic before kick-off and members of the Flanders Welsh War Memorial at Langemark will be attendance at the match.

Asked about the IFA's decision not to follow the FA and SFA's lead on poppies, Northern Ireland manager Michael O'Neill said: "I have a lot of influence, none of it exists at FIFA.

"This is a decision that is made by FIFA, I think the association have done everything in their power to mark the occasion with the utmost respect, we will do that as a group as well.

"We didn't feel it was the right thing as an association to violate the regulation. As a group of players and as a management team we're happy that the decision's been made and we can focus on the football now."

more courts articles

DUP calls for measures to prevent Northern Ireland from becoming 'magnet' for asylum seekers DUP calls for measures to prevent Northern Ireland from becoming 'magnet' for asylum seekers
UK's Illegal Migration Act should be disapplied in Northern Ireland, judge rules UK's Illegal Migration Act should be disapplied in Northern Ireland, judge rules
Former prisoner given indefinite hospital order for killing Irishman in London Former prisoner given indefinite hospital order for killing Irishman in London

More in this section

FAI headquarters FAI broker deal to lift block on DDSL's participation in Kennedy and Gaynor Cups
Stephen Kenny 16/5/2024 Stephen Kenny sold on Kelleher vision but no Kerr reconciliation 
Roy Keane’s ghost looms over new Man United treble documentary Roy Keane’s ghost looms over new Man United treble documentary
Sport Push Notifications

By clicking on 'Sign Up' you will be the first to know about our latest and best sporting content on this browser.

Sign Up
Sport
Newsletter

Latest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers

Sign up
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited