Teams make plea over F1 rules

The Formula One Teams’ Association have today called on the World Motor Sport Council and FIA Senate to intervene in the budget cap row.

The Formula One Teams’ Association have today called on the World Motor Sport Council and FIA Senate to intervene in the budget cap row.

The FIA’s announcement of the 2010 teams has, as expected, caused further uproar, notably Ferrari’s inclusion against their wishes.

Ferrari have made it clear they have no desire to compete in next year’s championship until, in their own words, “the condition of its entry are satisfied”.

Ferrari maintain that FIA president Max Mosley has failed to meet those conditions and is “in violation of Ferrari’s rights under a written agreement with the FIA”.

Red Bull Racing and Toro Rosso have also confirmed their loyalty to the Formula One Teams’ Association, despite the FIA granting them an unconditional entry.

As for McLaren, Renault, Toyota, BMW Sauber and Brawn GP, they have been given an extra week’s grace to submit their own unconditional entries, otherwise the FIA will return to the pool of potential new entrants.

In the wake of today’s announcement, the FOTA eight have drafted a letter to the World Council and FIA Senate imploring them to bring to an end the uncertainty of the last few weeks.

Under the heading ’Recommendations’, it reads: “We respectfully seek the intervention of the World Council to facilitate solutions to the present situation.

“We have attended numerous meetings with the FIA’s representatives and have been unable to make any substantive progress.

“The entry list has been published with five established teams listed as conditional entries and Ferrari, Red Bull and Toro Rosso, who against their will, have been classified as unconditional entries.

“All of these teams are united in their concerns about the present situation and are deeply worried about the crisis that Formula One now faces, a crisis that appears to be self generated.

“The teams wish to find a swift solution to the situation, but in case this cannot be done, they will reluctantly have to seek alternative solutions which protect them.

“In a final attempt to resolve this crisis, further meetings are scheduled for the next seven days.

“We would urge your support to ensure the outcome of these meetings achieves a solution that allows long established competitors to continue in their sport within a framework of sound governance and stability that will ensure the future and sustainability of Formula One.”

The bottom line is the teams no longer believe they can work with Mosley, with his governance at the heart of the issues that have raged since the 69-year-old unilaterally announced a voluntary €45m budget cap at the end of April.

Ferrari’s case centres around the fact they were granted a right of veto over any new regulations under a separate arrangement with the FIA in 2005.

They claim Mosley has breached that right, thus invalidating their contract with the FIA, and why they should not have been listed as an unconditional entrant today.

In the draft letter, FOTA seek “a balanced and transparent basis of governance” in the hope of restoring “a situation where the teams work in harmony with the Federation”.

Primarily, the letter focuses on the 2010 regulations and the cap which would have established a two-tier F1, which according to FOTA would cause “confusion and alienation of spectators, fans and the viewing public”.

The new teams – confirmed as Manor Grand Prix, Campos Grand Prix and Team US F1 - working within the cap would have been allowed a degree of technical freedom, whilst for those outside they would have been forced to apply this year’s rules.

Despite Mosley’s determination to cut costs and introduce fresh blood, FOTA argue Mosley “did not follow the FIA’s own statutes and principles and was too radical, even for the circumstances we face” (in terms of the serious economic crisis).

FOTA add: “We run a high risk of alienating and losing a number of Formula One teams who have been committed to Formula One for many years, both privateers and manufacturers.

“The prospect of losing eight well established and funded teams with provenance and history such as Ferrari and McLaren, and replacing them with the current unconditional entrants would be deeply disappointing to the teams and we believe to the detriment of Formula One as a whole.”

One grave area of concern surrounds the policing of a cap because as FOTA point out “it is the fundamental right of a competitor to manage and administer its business autonomously”.

FOTA have submitted an alternative policing proposal because in their eyes “it is unacceptable to consider the possibility that a large manufacturer or any team could be investigated for ’financial irregularities’ to establish compliance or to fend off accusations relating to a ’budget cap’.

“It would cause irreparable and irreversible damage to the team or manufacturer.”

It remains to be seen what action the remaining members of the World Council will take, in particular as Mosley is its head.

more courts articles

DUP calls for measures to prevent Northern Ireland from becoming 'magnet' for asylum seekers DUP calls for measures to prevent Northern Ireland from becoming 'magnet' for asylum seekers
UK's Illegal Migration Act should be disapplied in Northern Ireland, judge rules UK's Illegal Migration Act should be disapplied in Northern Ireland, judge rules
Former prisoner given indefinite hospital order for killing Irishman in London Former prisoner given indefinite hospital order for killing Irishman in London

More in this section

'Lot more to come' – Phil Foden hailed as writers' Footballer of the Year  'Lot more to come' – Phil Foden hailed as writers' Footballer of the Year 
Paul Mannion 13/5/2024 Run provincial championships alongside All-Ireland series like FA Cup, says Paul Mannion
Clare v Limerick - Munster GAA Hurling Championship Final S Christy O'Connor's talking points: Ennis to host the round robin’s biggest provincial opener 
ieStyle Live 2021 Logo
ieStyle Live 2021 Logo

IE Logo
Outdoor Trails

Discover the great outdoors on Ireland's best walking trails

IE Logo
Outdoor Trails

Sport
Newsletter

Latest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers

Sign up
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited