The Government was urged today to seek advice from independent archaeologists before deciding the destiny of the ancient seat of the Kings of Ireland.
Green Party TD Ciaran Cuffe accused the environment minister of adopting a “road-based bias” when choosing the route between Navan and Dublin, which cuts through the Tara Skyrne Valley.
He said that because it was the most economical option, Tara had been condemned from the outset for lying directly on the “desire line”, while other options had not been considered.
“In about a month’s time the minister will have to decide whether or not a motorway will slice through the archaeologically rich landscape of the Tara Skyrne valley,” he said.
Mr Cuffe suggested Dick Roche take advice from the independent archaeologists and academics attached to the Discovery Programme, set up by Charlie Haughey.
“You must seek independent advice,” he said. “Not just from your own department because the archaeologists there are very much under your wing.
“I suggest you seek the advice of those who have been looking at Tara in detail for over 10 years.”
Mr Roche told the Dáil that he had only a very limited part to play but insisted he was conscious of the significance of any decisions made.
He said that in the case of the M3 motorway the process involved a detailed environmental impact assessment in which archaeological factors were extensively addressed.
He stressed that once a motorway scheme has been approved any associated archaeological works were to be carried out in accordance with the directions the environment minister may issue.
“In determining the matter I will receive expert archaeological advice from my department,” he said. “I will also consult with the director of the Museum of Ireland.”