Shooting victim's family fail in challenge to have inquest delayed

The family of a murder victim have failed to get a High Court order halting an inquest into his death until they received certain information.

Shooting victim's family fail in challenge to have inquest delayed

The family of a murder victim have failed to get a High Court order halting an inquest into his death until they received certain information.

Liam Murray (42), a mechanic, was shot dead in his home at Rockbrook Cottage, Cruagh Road, Rathfarnham, Dublin, on St Patrick's day 2009.

A garda file was sent to the DPP, who decided there was insufficient evidence to charge anyone with the killing.

An inquest into his death was due to take resume in September 2015 when his sisters Fiona, Mairead, Siobhan and Patricia Murray, asked the High Court to stop it from going ahead because they were unhappy with the Coroner's decision not furnish them with a copy of the garda investigation file.

Ms Justice Mary Faherty refused their application saying she had not found any basis for doing so.

She said the garda investigation established that Mr Murray left a pub on the evening of March 17, 2009, and his last known contact was with a friend about an hour and a half later. Some people living near Mr Murray's home heard possible gunshots that night and he was found dead there three days later.

Some 1,900 lines of inquiry were followed up by gardai and almost 700 statements taken. Two people were arrested and the DPP later directed no criminal prosecutions be brought against them. Gardai say the investigation is still open.

Gardai provided a file to the Coroner who prepared draft depositions for the conduct of the inquest. The family's solicitor requested a copy of the garda file.

The Coroner furnished the depositions and post-mortem report and promised additional draft depositions from the gardai would be provided in due course.

The family complained they had not been furnished with a number of garda depositions including one relating to a statement made by someone who was understood to be a suspect and who had allegedly made a threat against Mr Murray.

They were unhappy with the amount of material furnished and believed it was insufficient to proceed with the inquest when it was scheduled for January 2014.

Following adjournments, the Coroner declined to release the papers the family sought.

The family got leave from the High Court in September 2015 to challenge the Coroner's decision. The Garda Commissioner was also a defendant.

It was argued on behalf of the family that, among other things, the narrative account of the circumstances leading to the death were seriously misleading and they feared such an narrative would be produced at the inquest.

They said there exists within the community innuendo and rumour about the death and the purpose of an inquest was to allay such rumours.

The information they sought was crucial to the integrity of the inquest and they were not seeking privileged information, it was argued.

The Coroner and the Commissioner opposed the application.

Ms Justice Faherty found what the family sought in its proceedings lay outside the provisions of the 1962 Coroners Act. This was so irrespective of whether they called in aid their constitutional rights or cite European Convention on Human Rights standards.

The reliefs they sought were therefore denied, she said.

more courts articles

Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van
Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman
Coronation Street actor William Roache (91) given three months to settle tax debt Coronation Street actor William Roache (91) given three months to settle tax debt

More in this section

Government to introduce State contributory pension for carers Government to introduce State contributory pension for carers
Drug death in Cork Prison could be linked to nitazene opiate Drug death in Cork Prison could be linked to nitazene opiate
Four people hospitalised following suspected arson at West Dublin home  Four people hospitalised following suspected arson at West Dublin home 
War_map
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited