Minister considering vote of no confidence in Eoghan Murphy

Government sources have confirmed that Junior Health Minister Catherine Byrne is considering abstaining or even voting against Housing Minister Eoghan Murphy in a motion of no confidence.

Minister considering vote of no confidence in Eoghan Murphy

Government sources have confirmed that Junior Health Minister Catherine Byrne is considering abstaining or even voting against Housing Minister Eoghan Murphy in a motion of no confidence.

The row is over a local housing issue in Dublin and has come to a head after the two previously fell out.

Such a move by Ms Byrne would be in direct defiance to an order by Taoiseach Leo Varadkar to support Mr Murphy in a Dail motion this week. Any such move could see the Dublin South Central TD face party sanctions or possibly even losing the whip.

The disagreement now threatens to engulf the Fine Gael party who are preparing to fight off a Sinn Fein vote and debate of no confidence in Mr Murphy tomorrow night in the Dail.

Government sources this afternoon have confirmed reports to the Irish Examiner that Ms Byrne has let party and government colleagues know her position.

The disagreement is over housing for the St Michael's site in Inchicore, Dublin.

Ms Byrne is opposed to government plans for rental accommodation on the site, claiming this will not benefit local families who want to live in the area.

Both Ms Byrne and Mr Murphy fell out over the issue during the summer, when the junior minister on a stage argued that the plans for St Michael's were the “worst ever” she had seen.

Housing Minister Eoghan Murphy
Housing Minister Eoghan Murphy

Sources are stressing that the Junior Health Minister has not threatened to vote no or indeed sought specific demands in exchange for her vote or support.

Nonetheless, sources point out that Mr Varadkar has insisted that TDs be in the chamber for motion tomorrow night and rally around the embattled housing minister.

Ms Byrne has made her feelings known privately. Not by letter or anything. She is considering her position. There isn't much love loss between the two over St Michael's.

“But she would have to consider an awful lot of things if she votes or abstains. The Taoiseach has made it clear. You could probably take a good guess at what might happen,” said a Fine Gael official familiar with the details of the row and Ms Byrne's position.

A separate parliamentary party source said:

“That could be the end of her ministerial career. I can't see how she would do this over Eoghan.”

more courts articles

Defendant in Cobh murder case further remanded in custody Defendant in Cobh murder case further remanded in custody
Further charges to be brought against accused in MV Matthew drugs haul case Further charges to be brought against accused in MV Matthew drugs haul case
Football fan given banning order after mocking Munich air disaster Football fan given banning order after mocking Munich air disaster

More in this section

Lonely Planet's Ultimate Travelist Potential extension of Wild Atlantic Way into Northern Ireland being considered
'Our maternity system is broken': Campaigners demand Commission of Investigation into baby deaths 'Our maternity system is broken': Campaigners demand Commission of Investigation into baby deaths
TOPSHOT-PALESTINIAN-ISRAEL-CONFLICT-AID 'You could say we escaped hell and it's still going on in there', mother says of fleeing Gaza
War_map
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited