Marie Fleming case 'could go to Europe'

A terminally ill Irish woman will take her landmark case for assisted suicide to Europe if she loses her appeal, supporters have revealed.

Marie Fleming case 'could go to Europe'

A terminally ill Irish woman will take her landmark case for assisted suicide to Europe if she loses her appeal, supporters have revealed.

Ireland’s highest court will rule tomorrow if multiple sclerosis (MS) sufferer Marie Fleming can choose to die peacefully at home in the arms of her partner Tom Curran without leaving him with a threat of jail.

The former university lecturer took her appeal to the seven-judge Supreme Court after losing a legal challenge at the High Court in Dublin.

Mr Curran admitted he is prepared for the worst and revealed his partner will consider taking her case to Europe if defeated again.

“We are not expecting them to overturn the judgment of the High Court,” he said.

“We will just have to wait and see and we will have to look at it from there.

“Europe is an option, it depends on the judgment. If there’s something in it that will allow us to go further we will.

“But I’m preparing us for the worst and I’m assuming it will go against us,” added the 65-year-old carer.

Ms Fleming, 59, of Arklow, Co Wicklow, can only move her head, lives in constant pain and cannot swallow. She suffers choking sessions which she fears will eventually kill her, the court was told during a four-day hearing in February and March.

She is not expected to attend the hearing, but Mr Curran will be there supported by his partner’s children Corrina and Simon and his son David.

Ms Fleming, who is in the final stages of MS, is not asking for someone to kill her, but wants assistance in putting a mask to her face or fitting a cannula in her arm, which she would activate by shaking her head or blowing into.

In her case against Ireland, the Attorney General and Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), the mother-of-two claims section 2.2 of the Criminal Law (Suicide) Act, which renders it an offence to aide, abet, counsel or procure the suicide of another, is unconstitutional on grounds that it breaches her personal autonomy rights under the Irish Constitution and European Convention on Human Rights.

Her legal team argued the ban is discriminatory and deprives an “entirely innocent” group of severely disabled people from suicide. They argue that she should be given the same right to die by suicide as an able-bodied person.

Ms Fleming wants court orders and declarations that the section of the act is invalid, allowing her to be lawfully assisted in taking her own life at a time of her choice.

However, the state argued that the blanket ban on assisted suicide does not discriminate against Ms Fleming as no-one has a constitutional right to be assisted with their death.

Barristers maintained that the decriminalisation of suicide in Ireland in 1993 did not give people a constitutional right to end their own life and raised concerns that any relaxation of the absolute ban could put vulnerable groups of people at risk.

The Chief Justice, Mrs Justice Susan Denham, said the case had raised “complex and important constitutional issues” when judgment was reserved.

The appeal was fast-tracked through the legal system after three judges at the High Court ruled in January that they could not support allowing a third party to bring about the death of another.

But they agreed the DPP, in this of all cases, would exercise discretion in a humane and sensitive fashion as to whether to prosecute or not.

Ms Fleming had given heartbreaking evidence to the specially convened court where she pleaded to be spared a horrible death and permission to be helped to die lawfully with dignity, surrounded by her family.

She did not attend the Supreme Court hearing.

The Irish Human Rights Commission is supporting Ms Fleming’s case and argued assisted suicide could be introduced with stringent conditions.

more courts articles

Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother
Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van
Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman

More in this section

McEntee: Group using arson to 'sow division and fear' in communities Four arrests in connection with fire at hotel earmarked for asylum seekers
Military accident Two further deaths on Irish roads after collisions in Roscommon and Dublin
Russian invasion of Ukraine Demand for State-provided beds to Ukrainians decreasing
War_map
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited