Challenge by mother and two Irish-born daughters to 'disproportionate' deportation orders struck out

A challenge by a mother and her two Irish-born daughters to orders for their deportation to the mother’s native Georgia has been struck out on consent at the High Court.

Challenge by mother and two Irish-born daughters to 'disproportionate' deportation orders struck out

By Ann O'Loughlin

A challenge by a mother and her two Irish-born daughters to orders for their deportation to the mother’s native Georgia has been struck out on consent at the High Court.

While the case was struck out today with no order, it is believed the deportation orders will be revoked.

The case concerns Lela Sivsivadze, who came here in 2003, and her two children, Mariam (aged 13) and Sofia (aged 8).

Mr Justice Richard Humphreys indicated last month he considered the deportation orders “disproportionate” for reasons including Ms Sivsivadze has been here for 15 years and her children, who have never been outside Ireland, are rooted here.

The judge indicated he intended to find against the Minister in a written judgment if necessary but adjourned the matter to allow lawyers for the Minister to consider what he had said.

Siobhán Stack SC, for the Minister, later secured a further adjournment so “certain options” could be put to the family.

When the case returned to court today, Mr Justice Humphreys agreed to strike out the proceedings on consent with no order.

The judge said, given the family was broken up seven years ago by a decision to deport Ms Sivsivadze’s husband, the children’s father, it would be positive for the authorities here to engage with the Georgian authorities to establish his whereabouts.

Garry O’Halloran BL, for the family, thanked the judge for expressing those views.

Previously, in urging the judge to overturn the deportation orders, Mr O’Halloran argued the children’s rights had not been properly taken into account.

The children have lived all their lives here, have never travelled outside Ireland, attend school here, speak Irish and know “almost nothing of Georgia”, he said.

The Minister for Justice’s 2017 decision to deport them arising from lies told by the mother in her asylum application 15 years ago was “so disproportionate” in a democratic society it’s “off the radar”, he said.

Those lies, the court heard, were to the effect she was fleeing an abusive stepfather in Georgia who did not exist. She was rather coming here to seek work.

Ms Sivsivadze disclosed the lies in earlier court proceedings unsuccessfully challenging the deportation in 2011 of her husband, also from Georgia. She has said he has no home or employment in Georgia and she and the children had nowhere to live if deported.

Mr O’Halloran said the case was essentially about the rights of children to have their position considered independently of the conduct of their parents. The older girl was very distressed arising from the deportation of her father and the family’s only contact with him is via Skype, he said.

Ms Stack, for the Minister, had argued Ms Sivsivadze previously secured permission to remain here on humanitarian grounds and that could be revoked if false and misleading information was provided.

Ms Sivsivadze’s parents are alive and still living in Georgia, her husband is also there and there was no evidence to support the claims he is homeless and unemployed, she argued.

During exchanges with counsel, Mr Justice Humphreys said Ms Sivsivadze has been here 15 years and the State had come down on her like a “ton of bricks” because she was either “honest or naive” enough to have owned up to lies.

more courts articles

Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother
Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van
Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman

More in this section

Irish homelessness Government criticised for missing social and affordable housing targets
National Risk Assessment for Ireland Tánaiste urges Israel ‘to show humanity’ and allow more aid into Gaza
Lego set based on RNLI lifeboat could soon become a reality Lego set based on RNLI lifeboat could soon become a reality
War_map
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited