Developer Paddy McKillen loses challenge to Anglo share assessment process

Developer Paddy McKillen has lost a High Court challenge to a process in which a Government-appointed assessor has been asked to come up with a valuation for shares in the nationalised former Anglo Irish Bank.

Developer Paddy McKillen loses challenge to Anglo share assessment process

Developer Paddy McKillen has lost a High Court challenge to a process in which a Government-appointed assessor has been asked to come up with a valuation for shares in the nationalised former Anglo Irish Bank.

Mr McKillen, who was a substantial shareholder in Anglo, last year brought judicial review proceedings over the short timescale the developer was given to respond to the role of the assessor in determining compensation for Anglo shareholders.

Under the Anglo Irish Bank Corporation Act in 2009, the Government provided for the extinguishment of certain rights in the bank, removal of certain people from office and payment of compensation for shareholders. At the time of nationalisation, Anglo shares had a "hope value" of 22 cent.

Nearly 10 years later in November 2018, assessor David Tynan of PwC was appointed to decide on that compensation.

As part of his challenge initiated last June, Mr McKillen was granted a stay on Mr Tynan publishing his final report for the Minister for Finance on the valuation pending determination or the legal proceedings.

Today, Mr Justice Brian O'Moore refused all reliefs sought by Mr McKillen.

Among Mr McKillen's argument were that there was a degree of vagueness about how Mr Tynan's assessment was being carried out and that he had not been given enough time to make submissions to Mr Tynan.

The application was opposed by Mr Tynan.

The judge said evidence was provided on Mr McKillen's behalf from economics professor Constantin Gurdgiev and former AIB director Bernard Somers in relation to shareholding valuation.

Mr McKillen had not satisfied him that either of these two men "qualify as experts" in this field and even if they did their evidence was of "no real value".

It was on the basis of their evidence Mr McKillen made out that he needed certain information to make a meaningful submission to Mr Tynan.

As their evidence was not capable of supporting this, he had not discharged the burden on him of establishing it was information which was required by him to make a meaningful submission to the assessor, the judge said.

He had also not discharged the onus on him of showing Mr Tynan's decision not to provide the information was unreasonable, he said. A refusal to extend the time Mr McKillen had to make a submission was also not unreasonable.

Mr McKillen had also not succeeded in making out a case of objective bias on the part of Mr Tyrnan, he said.

more courts articles

Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother
Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van
Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman

More in this section

FILE PHOTO The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission has cleared the purchase of Goodbody Stockbrokers by AIB END Goodbody Stockbrokers fined over €1.2m by Central Bank over rules breaches
Nottingham City Centre Stock Irish staff at the Body Shop wait for wages as retailer shuts stores in the Republic
Ryanair comments on Norwegian Ryanair boss O'Leary's spat with Transport Minister over Dublin Airport escalates
IE logo
Devices


UNLIMITED ACCESS TO THE IRISH EXAMINER FOR TEAMS AND ORGANISATIONS
FIND OUT MORE

The Business Hub
Newsletter

News and analysis on business, money and jobs from Munster and beyond by our expert team of business writers.

Sign up
ie logo
Puzzles Logo

Play digital puzzles like crosswords, sudoku and a variety of word games including the popular Word Wheel

Lunchtime News
Newsletter

Keep up with the stories of the day with our lunchtime news wrap.

Sign up
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited