Pistorius neighbour back in court to give evidence

Oscar Pistorius’ lead defence lawyer grilled one of the neighbours of the star athlete today, questioning the man over how many gunshots he thought he heard on the night of Reeva Steenkamp’s death.

Pistorius neighbour back in court to give evidence

Oscar Pistorius’ lead defence lawyer grilled one of the neighbours of the star athlete today, questioning the man over how many gunshots he thought he heard on the night of Reeva Steenkamp’s death.

Lawyer Barry Roux said Charl Johnson’s testimony and statements to police were manipulated to match those of his wife, who testified on the opening day, and were an attempt to “incriminate the accused”.

“I can confidently say I heard gunshots,” Mr Johnson insisted on cross-examination by Mr Roux on the fourth day of Pistorius’ murder trial. Later, Mr Johnson said: “I’m convinced that I heard a lady’s voice.”

Mr Roux argues that prosecution witnesses Mr Johnson and his wife are mistaken over what they heard on the night Pistorius killed his girlfriend by firing four times through a toilet door.

Mr Roux says the banging sounds were actually Pistorius hitting a toilet door with a bat and the screaming was the distressed athlete calling for help – and there were no sounds from Ms Steenkamp. Pistorius says he shot her by mistake.

Mr Johnson said he “disputed” some of what Mr Roux was saying and described in more detail what he heard that night. The Johnsons live 177 metres from the villa where Ms Steenkamp died.

“The fear ... in the lady person’s calls contrasted with a very monotone male voice,” Mr Johnson testified. “The man almost sounded embarrassed to be calling for help.”

Mr Roux did get Mr Johnson to concede right at the end of the court session that he never heard what he thought was the woman’s voice and the man’s voice at the same time. Mr Roux wants to show that it was the same person – Pistorius - screaming.

The sequence of events soon after 3 am on the morning of February 14 last year is a critical aspect of the case. Prosecutors say there was a loud argument between Pistorius and Ms Steenkamp before the shooting. Pistorius says there was no argument and he killed the 29-year-old model, by accident thinking she was an intruder in his home.

Mr Roux, who was at times interrupted by the judge to clarify some of his questions, also attempted to throw doubt on the validity of Mr Johnson’s testimony and that of his wife Burger. Mr Roux said their versions were vague and different in statements to police and in notes they made in the weeks after the killing. Then, the couple’s stories and recollection of the events of that night became suspiciously similar later, Mr Roux said.

“Your intention is a design to sideline and incriminate the accused,” Mr Roux said to Mr Johnson. “It’s a design on your side to incriminate, and it’s unfortunate.”

Mr Johnson, who appeared stronger and surer today than he was Wednesday, replied: “I have no reason to design an incriminating statement.”

Pistorius, a double-amputee runner who competed at the 2012 Olympics, is charged with murder with premeditation after shooting Ms Steenkamp. Dressed in a dark suit, Pistorius arrived earlier than usual for proceedings and sat alone and staring ahead before the judge arrived.

more courts articles

Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother
Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van
Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman

More in this section

Paramedics among 16 people killed by Israeli airstrikes in Lebanon Paramedics among 16 people killed by Israeli airstrikes in Lebanon
French legislators ponder law to ban discrimination based on a person’s hair French legislators ponder law to ban discrimination based on a person’s hair
China ends tariffs on Australian wine as relations between countries thaw China ends tariffs on Australian wine as relations between countries thaw
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited