‘FIFA officials violate the norms and standards of good conduct’, says ex-UN chief in resignation email

The remarkably undiplomatic language was used by the former United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights in her resignation email to FIFA general secretary Fatma Samoura.

‘FIFA officials violate the norms and standards of good conduct’, says ex-UN chief in resignation email

The former United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights told FIFA she could no longer serve on its governance committee because its officials "violate the norms and standards of good conduct".

The remarkably undiplomatic language was used by South African judge Navi Pillay in her resignation email to FIFA general secretary Fatma Samoura, a former UN official herself, on May 17.

Now published on the website of the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) committee, the email confirms Pillay's decision to quit the committee following the abrupt removal of its chairman, Portuguese academic and politician Miguel Maduro, a week earlier.

Having already told Samoura of her "dissatisfaction" with the decision on the phone, Pillay reminds Samoura they have both completed an online course on FIFA's ethics code which requires them to report cases of "improper interference" or the "exercise of influence or pressure".

"In compliance with this regulation, the facts of undue influence exerted on the chair to change a recommendation made by the (governance committee), were made known to me," Pillay wrote.

"As a judge and former UN High Commissioner, I adhere to principled conduct at all times and cannot countenance serving in an institution whose officials violate the norms and standards of good conduct, that they themselves adopted.

"I remain concerned that the (committee's) independent functioning will not be respected. Kindly accept my resignation from the governance committee of FIFA."

The case of interference to which Pillay refers was discussed by Maduro in his appearance before the DCMS committee on Wednesday.

The governance expert told MPs how FIFA president Gianni Infantino and Samoura had tried to persuade him not to block Russian deputy prime minister Vitaly Mutko from standing for election to FIFA's ruling council.

For Maduro, Mutko's Russian position was an obvious breach of FIFA rules against governmental interference in football and he was therefore not eligible for a senior position within the game.

Infantino and Samoura, however, told him blocking Mutko would jeopardise the success of next year's World Cup in Russia and bring down Infantino's presidency.

Maduro stood firm, Mutko withdrew and Maduro was removed from office two months later, less than a year after being appointed to lead FIFA's attempts to rebuild its image after the scandals of the Sepp Blatter era.

Soon after Maduro's exit, Pillay, British human rights expert Ron Popper and American law professor Joseph Weiler quit the governance committee in protest.

The background to this was explained in remarkable and damning detail by Maduro, who also revealed that Weiler has made a formal complaint to FIFA's ethics committee about how the governance committee was treated by the organisation's leadership.

In a statement on Wednesday, FIFA said it has "noted" Maduro's comments to the DCMS committee but denied it has ever "put the competencies of previous committee members into question" and said it has "always respected their decisions".

It also said it was "normal...logical and even desirable" for Maduro and the other independent committee heads to be in "regular contact" with FIFA's administration and to portray this as "undue influence is factually incorrect".

It added: "The independence of FIFA's committees and the success of FIFA's reform process will only be measured by the decisions taken in the future and not by personal opinions."

more courts articles

Football fan given banning order after mocking Munich air disaster Football fan given banning order after mocking Munich air disaster
Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother
Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van

More in this section

Bayern Munich v Arsenal - UEFA Champions League - Quarter-Final - Second Leg - Allianz Arena Kimmich goal ends Gunners' Champions League dream in Munich
FC Bayern München v Arsenal FC: Quarter-final Second Leg - UEFA Champions League 2023/24 Arsenal's steady, stoic showing proves they have another hill to climb
Manchester City v Real Madrid - UEFA Champions League - Quarter-Final - Second Leg - Etihad Stadium Rude awakening for City as champions bow out to Madrid on penalties
Sport Push Notifications

By clicking on 'Sign Up' you will be the first to know about our latest and best sporting content on this browser.

Sign Up
Sport
Newsletter

Latest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers

Sign up
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited