Citizens' Assembly to hear first formal debate today between both sides on abortion issue

Latest: The chairperson of the Citizens' Assembly has said the term "fatal foetal abnormalities" will continue to be used during its discussions of the Eighth Amendment.

Citizens' Assembly to hear first formal debate today between both sides on abortion issue

Update 11.10am: The chairperson of the Citizens' Assembly has said the term "fatal foetal abnormalities" will continue to be used during its discussions of the Eighth Amendment.

Ms Justice Mary Laffoy made the ruling following objections from anti-abortion campaigners, who believe the term is subjective and suggests death is an inevitable outcome of such conditions. They say the term "life-limiting condition" should be used instead.

The Assembly is today continuing its examination of the Eighth Amendment.

Opening today's session, Justice Laffoy said "fatal foetal abnormalities" is a widely used expression in international law, and excluding it would be inappropriate.

She said: "The term, or a variation of it, has been, and is, used in international law to describe exactly the topic we are going to hear about today.

"To exclude its usage at the Assembly would therefore, in my view, be inappropriate. It will therefore continue to be used by the Assembly throughout the remaining weekends, as appropriate."

Justice Mary Laffoy.
Justice Mary Laffoy.

Earlier:

The Citizens' Assembly will hold its first debate between pro-choice and anti-abortion speakers on the Eighth Amendment today.

The body is addressing Ireland's restrictions on abortion and whether or not the Government should hold a referendum on the matter.

It has been criticised by the Catholic Bishops and by the anti-abortion lobby for its use of the term 'fatal foetal abnormalities' in its agenda setting out this weekend's work, saying the term suggests death is an inevitable outcome of such conditions. They say the term 'life-limiting condition' should be used instead.

The Pro Life Campaign has said the Assembly has a pre-determined outcome for a referendum on the issue.

Meanwhile, spokesperson for the Terminations for Medical Reasons Gerry Edwards said he was concerned the assembly's work might be delayed.

"They are talking about making recommendations by May to the Oireachtas, but we have no firm commitment from the Government or the Oireachtas as to what might happen next. There are no timelines," he said.

"We now have Archbishop Martin making references to the papal visit being used as a rallying point to defend the Eighth Amendment. There's no reason why a referendum should still be pending by the time the Pope is due to visit Ireland (August 2018)."

more courts articles

‘Suicide mission’ to threaten Roman Abramovich associate, court told ‘Suicide mission’ to threaten Roman Abramovich associate, court told
Former DUP leader Jeffrey Donaldson arrives at court to face sex charges Former DUP leader Jeffrey Donaldson arrives at court to face sex charges
Case against Jeffrey Donaldson to be heard in court Case against Jeffrey Donaldson to be heard in court

More in this section

PSNI stock Controlled explosion carried out after school science lab alert
Former NI state pathologist to conduct Nkencho postmortem Gardaí involved in fatal shooting of George Nkencho will not be prosecuted
Ireland v Italy - Guinness Six Nations - Aviva Stadium President Michael D Higgins says he will be ‘recovered’ in weeks after mild stroke
War_map
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited